Mome

MomeFinally got my copy of Mome #1 through in the post via a long and tortuous process I won’t bore you with, but suffice to say it was worth it.

I’ve always had a soft spot for comics anthologies of the literary bent as they can give a really good snapshot of how seemingly disparate creators can be connected. I’d been intrigued by Mome for a while now, partly because of the names attached to it (Jordan Crane mainly, for his previous work publishing the best anthology of the late 90s, Non) but also by Fantagraphics publishing a showcase anthology of upcoming cartoonists.

Fantagraphics have always seemed, to me at least, a few steps behind when it came to the current crop of cutting edge creators, leaving such sifting of the minicomics scene to the likes of Drawn and Quarterly and Top Shelf. Maybe this was to do with their long and important association with the previous generation of underground and alternative creators, maybe they were just biding their time to see what came through, I can’t really say, but with Mome, they’re throwing themselves headfirst with a roster of pretty much unknown talent, and that alone is noteworthy. Beyond Crane’s design involvement this doesn’t feel like a Fantagraphics book and as such marks an interesting development for the company.

What’s immediately apparent is that it was worth the wait. With most anthologies you can rely on a good third, often more, not working for you but there are only two strips in here I’m not liking. And even then it’s not so much the strips themselves that are inferior, more that I just didn’t get on with them, so I won’t identify them here. The rest of the book is great, so much so I don’t want to pull out any one specific artist above the rest. Which is making for a really dull review, I know. Ah well.

What’s interesting about Mome is that the core roster of artists will stay the same throughout the series so we’ll get to see these talents evolving over the years. Another nice thing is that while it all hangs together really well there’s no specifically identifiable traits shared by the cartoonists. If they are bouncing off each other it’s not in a superficial surface way.

Fantagraphics currently have the best company blog in the comics industry (it tells you about what they’re publishing and is interesting – how revolutionary!) showing they actually understand the internet and now have an anthology that is both forward looking and a really good read. Mome sets them up well for the future, I feel.

Interview with co-editor Eric Reynolds.

This entry was posted in Posts. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Mome

  1. SM says:

    But, by refusing to identify which parts work for you, and which parts don’t, it is quite a strange review (I’m steering clear of ‘dull’)

    FWIW, I bought it based on the promise of Hornschemier (sp?) and I really enjoyed both his work and the interview with him. Which might be why I was less enamoured with issue 2 – the interview is with, er, the cartoonist who did the cover on ish 1. Can’t remember her name.

    That said, I hope it succeeds. Its a nice experiment and I’ll be continuing to buy it.

  2. Pete Ashton says:

    It might help if you think of it less as a review and more as a notice.

    That said, I’m thinking I might review it properly now.

  3. PaulHD says:

    By strange coincidence I just got this through work. I really like Gabriel Bell’s stuff (more so then the anthology collection Alternative Comics put out a year or so ago) and am quite interested in reading the interview with her. Not familiar with Andrea Arp’s work, but will keep an eye out in the future. Strange that such an obvious concept as having a regular group of creators on the same anthology should be so exciting but after reading the SPX books over the last few years it seems like a grand idea.

  4. e-tat says:

    I’m not sure if you read D’log, so here’s something that might be of interest:
    Strip Search:
    Strip Search is looking for the best new comic creators in the West Midlands, for their new support programme.”

    Let us know if it’s a cynical ploy, eh?

  5. Pete Ashton says:

    Yeah, Strip Search has been running for a while now. If it were 5-10 years ago I’d be very interested and potentially involved but not so much these days.

    It’s a good thing though.