Alex from the band Devil and Casey Jones emailed a while back ostensibly to tell me about a gig they were doing (which, as usual, I couldn’t attend due to work…) and informed me of a book that mentions the Number 11 Outer Circle bus route in Birmingham which, as you know, I’m planning to write a book about.
The book was Clare Morrall’s Astonishing Splashes of Colour. Since I’m on a perpetual budget I was a bit wary about forking out for a novel but I noticed Amazon had it listed as second hand for a quid which, with postage, worked out at £3.75, which seemed reasonable, so I ordered it. A couple of days later it arrived - an ex-library copy with the first few pages falling out but what do you expect for a quid.
And it turned out to be really good indeed. Not much useful Outer Circle stuff (it’s more a plot device than a description of the route) but a thoroughly enjoyable read and quite unique. I wholeheartedly recommend it to everyone, Birmingham based or not.
Having enjoyed the book I starting thinking about the fact that it had cost me a quid of which the author would see nothing. Admittedly if I’d bought it new the author would only have seen about 50p, if that, but those royalties add up over time. Since the book is still in print I’ve also done the publisher out of a sale which, when you’re printing in bulk, can be a significant thing.
Jeanette Winterson wrote an article in the Guardian recently (which of course I can’t find online for looking…) the gist of which was how Amazon’s listing second hand books was really not a good thing at all and tantamount to stealing. It’s not like I stumbled across the book in a dusty shop - I was actively looking for it and contemplating paying full price but was given the opportunity to buy it for next to nothing with the profits going to some dealer in The Wirrall.
But, as usual, while raising an interesting point Winterson is wrong. I probably wouldn’t have paid full price (my Amazon basket is overflowing with full price books I’m probably never going to be able to afford to buy) and having enjoyed the book have recommended it to others, including you. Nobody loses, everyone wins.
That said, it would be nice to have the option of financially compensating Morrall for the work she put into writing the book. If Amazon, or someone else, set up a system where I could pay another quid of which a decent percentage would go to the author I’d probably do that. A system, the Public Lending Right, already exists for library books where authors get around 5p each time their titles are borrowed so it shouldn’t be too hard to piggy-back this. Make it simple with a link on each eligible title on Amazon, something like “I have read this book second hand and would like to pay the author”, and I’m sure a reasonable number of people would be up for it. And naturally the commission on those donations would be another revenue stream for Amazon.
Of course I could send a cheque to the publishers (or just look her up in the phone book and stick a quid through her letterbox) but am I, or anyone else, realistically going to do that? Of course not.
The other obvious place this sort of thing would work is for music, not just CDs bought second hand but for stuff downloaded via P2P. However I suspect the record industry would consider this sort of enlightened initiative akin to negotiating with terrorists…